Thursday, February 01, 2007

OK Omar, What's Next?

So, yesterday brought us some interesting news from Metsland. Bad news, and worser news. First the bad news.

What was rumored a couple of weeks ago has happened, Ruben Sierra has signed a minor league contract and will be in camp. So, add another bat to the mix for the 5th outfielder spot (I say 5th 'cause ain't no one taking Highlight Endy Chavez' spot as #4). We now have Ben Johnson, Lastings Milledge and David Newham in the running. Now, young Lastings is more than likely going to start in AAA New Orleans, unless he absolutely crushes the ball in the spring, and does not look completely lost in the outfield. The problem I have with that is he could use more time learning the corner spots than he will get as a reserve in NY. Johnson could be this year's Xavier Nady, which depending on your point of view is either a good thing (some pop in the bat) or a bad thing (alas, lots of wind generated from missed pitches). Newhan has some (limited) experience playing first, but with 58 year old Juio Franco around, odds are he will not get a spot.

So what about Sierra? Well, there was a time where he was a feared hitter. Lets see, was it in 2004 when he had 17 hr's and 65 rbi's for the Yankees, while batting 244? Nope. Was it in 2005, he appeared in 61 games, hitting 229? Nope. How about last year? Not so much, as he played in 14 games for the Twins, hitting a Matsuiesque .179. I would say the last time he was feared was 2001, when he hit 291, with 23 HR, 67 RBI in 94 games for the Rangers. Even that was not exactly a stellar year.

So what is the benefit of Ruben Sierra? I'm not quite sure. There is the thought that he could play in NO and act as a mentor for Lastings and Carlos Gomez, along with other young players. There is the thought he could provide "pop" off the bench. In my mind, neither of these is a good plan. For the latter, his "pop" is about as lively as Barbaro. For the former, it's not like Ruben was ever a great fielder. I usuually don't disagree with Omar that much, since he has risen to be a successful GM of a Major League Baseball team, and I am just some schmuck with a computer, but I just don't see the rationale here. The signing makes little sense.

The worser news is more troublesome. Dave Williams (DW2 to my friends of on Metsgeek) had surgery for a hernieted disc in his neck. The team will not know how long it will be until he can resume baseball activities until next week possibly, depending on tests at that time. This is bad news, as DW2 was in the running for at least the long man role in the pen (ala Darren Oliver) if not the #5 starter slot. DW2 is not the most overpowering guy, but he pitched well for the Mets last year in several starts, with few total clunkers. So, the #5 competition becomes a little less crowded, and the options for the long guy out of the pen change as well. I'll have more to say on this as Spring Training gets underway and I start looking at how guys are doing. Luckily, Omar brought in a lot of arms this offseason, so quantity is there.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Solid post as always my man.

I think the Sierra signing was made almost 100% for him to hang out in AAA and make sure Lastings keeps himself in check and all that.

I also think he's like a super-emergency OF for the big club in case we get hit with anthrax or something. If Sierra is on the big club outside of say septemeber callups, the metties are in twuble!

Rickey said...

Yeah but if the want someone around to keep Lastings in line, can't they just hire somebody's stern grandfather or something? You know, somebody to tell Lastings old-timey stories and hand out Werther's Originals?

Anonymous said...

Rickey, I feel like Frank Robinson is the perfect guy for that job. Hire Frank Omar!!!

Anonymous said...

I disagree that the Ruben Sierra signing is "bad" news. It's just another in a long line of no-risk/potential-reward veteran signings.

We said the same thing about Jose Valentin and Endy Chavez last year.

Sierra will come to training camp, probably suck, and probably not make the team. If so, no harm done.

The only way that this hurts us is if Willie develops an unjustifiable love for the guy and proceeds to give him playing time over younger, more qualified players. But I don't really think that's gonna happen.

--Craig/clmetsfan

Ed in Westchester said...

Someone like, oh maybe:

RICKEY!

That would be a role model. Rickey could, in addition to making him a better base stealer, show him how to speak in the third person, and to play cards. It would be great!

Ed in Westchester said...

craig - you make good points. I for one railed about Valentin (not so much Chavez, as I was not that familiar with him).
However, Willie has shown a tendancy to fall in love with vets. I just don't think there is that much upside here. I don't even think he is of that much value as a mentor.

Anonymous said...

Ed,

Sierra had a really good reputation both with Texas and the Skanks as being a mentor to all the young kids he could get to listen.


And I think Milledge will respect him more because he's still playing and not some old man coach, he's an old man player/coach! ;)

Ed in Westchester said...

Dep - I was not aware of that rep. That being the case, it is further proof that sometimes I talk before I have all the facts.

Thanks all for sharing and for stopping by. I feel so loved.

Anonymous said...

We do love ya big guy :) We can't keep it in anymore!

When you couldnt post at the geek for a few months cuz of firewalls or whatever, i missed ya A LOT!!!

Here's an NYT article about sierra that talks a little to his mentoring. of course it his agent doing the talking in this article, so a grain o' salt is required. but deppy is always looking for that silver lining in any move the mets make. Rose is a purty color!

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/16/sports/baseball/16chass.html?ex=1326603600&en=f20aad2a85e779ec&ei=5088&partner=rssnyt&emc=rss

Chris said...

Ruben Sierra is good people apparrently.

Ed in Westchester said...

Hall of Famer Joe Morgan - did you ever play with Ruben? How does he stack up to your teammates?

Mookie McFly said...

If that is Joe, he would say something like:

He's no Tony Perez...but who is? Sierra does the little things. I haven't read Moneyball and I won't but you just can't measure hustle and heart.

Mike said...

Wow. So Sierra has become a "good guy."

Who'd a thunk it? I'd still rather go with Rickey.